Methodology
How SecondLook decides.
Every verdict comes from public federal data and published law. Hard rules decide what can be decided with certainty. Ranked search finds candidate recalls, and an optional AI step reads messy listings and photos. You can always see which of them produced a result.
01 · Data
Every CPSC recall since 2005, kept current
The recall corpus comes from the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission's public Recalls REST API. A compact snapshot ships with the app, about 7,200 recalls with titles, product names, model numbers, hazards, remedies, injuries and retailer information. At runtime the server asks the same API for anything published after the snapshot and merges it in. That refreshes every six hours, so a recall announced this week is searchable today.
There's no account and no application database: SecondLook doesn't save the listings you check. The server briefly holds rate-limit data (IP address and request times) in memory, errors go to the hosting provider's logs, and a shareable link carries the listing text in its URL. Label photos are read in your browser. With the AI step off, as in this deployment, they aren't uploaded.
02 · Law
Federal sale bans, applied as rules
Some products can't legally be sold at all, regardless of brand or recall status. These checks are deterministic because a ban is a legal fact, not a probability.
Inclined infant sleepers are bannedBanned
Inclined sleepers for infants (sleep surface inclined more than 10°) are banned hazardous products under the Safe Sleep for Babies Act, which prohibits their manufacture, sale, distribution and import in the U.S. The Fisher-Price Rock 'n Play is the best-known example.
Safe Sleep for Babies Act of 2022 (Pub. L. 117-126); CPSC final rule effective Sept. 15, 2023 · source
Padded crib bumpers are bannedBanned
Padded crib bumpers, vinyl bumper guards and vertical slat covers are banned hazardous products. They cannot legally be sold. Non-padded mesh liners are not covered by the ban.
Safe Sleep for Babies Act of 2022 (Pub. L. 117-126); CPSC final rule effective Sept. 15, 2023 · source
Drop-side cribs are illegal to sellBanned
Since June 28, 2011, full-size and non-full-size cribs must meet federal standards that effectively ended drop-side designs. Selling, reselling or donating a crib that doesn't meet them is illegal. That includes garage sales and online listings.
16 CFR parts 1219 and 1220 (crib safety standards, effective June 28, 2011) · source
Cribs made before mid-2011 are likely illegal to resellStandard: verify
Cribs made before June 28, 2011 are very likely to fail the current federal crib standard, and selling a noncompliant crib is illegal. Ask the seller for the manufacture date printed on the crib's label.
16 CFR parts 1219 and 1220 (crib safety standards, effective June 28, 2011) · source
Lawn darts are bannedBanned
Lawn darts with elongated tips were banned in 1988 after child deaths. Their sale is prohibited in the United States.
16 CFR 1306 (Ban of Lawn Darts) · source
Infant sleep products must meet a federal standardStandard: verify
Since 2022, any product marketed for infant sleep must meet the standard for a crib, bassinet, play yard or bedside sleeper. In-bed sleepers, baby nests and loungers marketed for sleep often do not. Consumer Reports found these on every major resale site in 2026. Don't use one for sleep.
16 CFR 1236 (Infant Sleep Products, effective June 23, 2022) · source
Selling any recalled consumer product is also prohibited under Section 19 of the Consumer Product Safety Act (15 U.S.C. § 2068).
03 · Matching
Bridging how people list and how recalls are written
Consumer Reports found recalled Rock 'n Play sleepers listed as “baby sleeper/rocker”, “floor cradle” and “bassinet”. The official search expects the exact product name. SecondLook closes that gap in four layers:
- Vocabulary bridge. A taxonomy of 23 product concepts maps listing language (“pack n play”, “sleeper/rocker”, “dresser”) to the vocabulary recall notices use (“play yard”, “inclined sleeper”, “chest”, “tip-over”).
- Ranked retrieval. Field-weighted BM25 over titles, product names, product types, firms and descriptions, including two-word phrases, so “Rock 'n Play” beats a generic “play”.
- Brand resolution. Brands are resolved against recalling firms and licensed brand names (“Sharper Image-branded… by Allstar”). A brand mismatch heavily discounts a candidate.
- Exact identifiers. Model numbers and UPCs from the listing or label photo are matched against the recall's identifiers. An exact hit from the same brand is the strongest signal there is.
Each candidate is graded strong, possible or weak. The interface shows why each one matched, and pulls the identifying details (model numbers, date codes, sale windows) out of the notice so you know what to ask the seller.
04 · AI
Where AI helps, and where it isn't allowed to decide
When an Anthropic API key is configured, Claude handles two narrow, structured steps:
- Understanding. It reads the listing (and the label photo, if any) and returns the brand, likely official product line, visible model numbers, and the phrases a recall notice would use. This feeds the search; it doesn't replace it.
- Adjudication. It compares the listing with the recalls the engine retrieved and explains, in plain language, whether each is the same product and what to check on the physical item.
Claude never invents recalls: it can only judge candidates retrieved from CPSC data, and responses are schema-validated. Federal bans are never decided by the model. If AI is unavailable, the rules engine still produces a complete result, and every result is labeled with the engine that produced it.
Without a photo-capable AI step, label photos are still read: text recognition runs entirely in your browser (Tesseract.js), so the photo never leaves your device.
05 · Limits
What SecondLook can't tell you
- “No matching recall found” is not a safety certification. Listings are often incomplete, and some unsafe products were never recalled.
- The corpus covers CPSC consumer-product recalls since 2005. Vehicles and car seats with NHTSA campaigns, food, drugs and cosmetics are outside it.
- Most recalls cover specific model numbers or production dates. A strong match means “confirm with the seller”, not “definitely recalled”, unless the identifiers match.
- SecondLook is independent and isn't affiliated with the CPSC. Always confirm on the official notice linked in each result.